Simon became inarticulate in his effort to express mankind's essential illness. Someone spoke out of turn.
"May be he means it is some sort of ghost."
Piggy took the conch out of his hands. His voice was indignant.
"I don't believe in no ghost-ever!"
Jack was up, angry.
"Who cares what you believe-Fatty!"
He started a fight with Piggy. Ralph interceded to stop them. A hushed and anonymous voice broke in.
"Perhaps that's what the beast is-A ghost."
The Assembly was shaken as by a wind. Ralph said,
"There is too much talking out of turn. We will have a vote on them; on ghosts, I mean; and then go to the shelters because we are all tired."
He thought for a moment formulating the question.
"Who thinks there may be ghosts?"
Piggy said, "I didn't vote for no ghosts. Remember that all of you! what are we? Humans? or animals? or savages? What's grown ups going to think? Going off- hunting wild rams-letting fires out-and now!"
"You shut up, you fat slug!"
Question 1: How does Simon struggle to articulate his thoughts, and what interpretation does someone offer for his words?
Answer: Simon becomes inarticulate in his attempt to express mankind's essential illness. Someone suggests that he might mean it is some sort of ghost.
Question 2: How does Piggy respond to the suggestion of ghosts, and what is Jack's reaction to Piggy's response?
Answer: Piggy indignantly rejects the idea of ghosts, stating that he doesn't believe in them. Jack becomes angry and insults Piggy, calling him "Fatty" and starting a fight with him.
Question 3: What suggestion does an anonymous voice make about the nature of the beast, and how does it impact the assembly?
Answer: An anonymous voice suggests that the beast might be a ghost. This suggestion shakes the assembly, causing a disturbance akin to being shaken by a wind.
Question 4: How does Ralph attempt to restore order to the assembly, and what decision does he make regarding the discussion about ghosts?
Answer: Ralph intervenes to stop the fight between Jack and Piggy and then suggests having a vote on the topic of ghosts. He decides to vote on whether anyone believes there may be ghosts and then suggests going to the shelters because everyone is tired.
Question 5: How does Piggy emphasize his stance on the discussion about ghosts, and what broader question does he raise?
Answer: Piggy emphasizes that he didn't vote for ghosts and urges the others to remember that. He questions whether they are humans, animals, or savages, expressing concern about the impression they are giving to adults.
Question 6: How does Jack respond to Piggy's remarks, and what does this interaction reveal about the dynamics among the boys?
Answer: Jack tells Piggy to shut up and insults him by calling him a "fat slug." This interaction reveals the power struggle and the bullying dynamics among the boys, with Jack asserting dominance over Piggy through verbal abuse.